Best Income Protection Insurance in NZ: How Policies Compare

There’s no single best income protection policy in New Zealand. The right one depends on how your payments are worked out, how the insurer defines being unable to work, and how long you’d wait before you’re paid.
This guide compares what six NZ insurers publish about their income protection, including claims figures, so you know what to ask before you choose.
Last reviewed: November 2026
General information only. Cover terms change, so check the current policy wording before you decide.

The Key Facts
Income protection replaces part of your income if illness or injury stops you working. These are the details that make the biggest difference.
Some policies can cover up to 75% of your income, subject to the insurer’s limits and the type of cover, such as with Chubb Life.
Payments are worked out on an agreed value, your income at claim time (indemnity), or a mix (loss of earnings).
On the policies we checked, waiting periods run from 2 weeks to 2 years. A longer wait lowers your premium.
Benefit periods range from 1 or 2 years to age 65 or 70.
Most income protection is reduced by ACC payments for the same injury, but some cover types aren’t.
ACC only covers injuries (ACC). Income protection is the main way to cover lost income from illness.
Who Has the Best Income Protection in NZ?
No insurer is best for everyone. Policies differ on five things that decide what you’d actually be paid: how the payment is calculated, how “unable to work” is defined, the waiting period, the benefit period, and what’s deducted, such as ACC. The best policy is the one that’s strongest on the points that matter for your job and budget.
Agreed value, indemnity or loss of earnings. This decides whether you need to prove your income at claim time.
Whether the insurer assesses your ability to do your usual job or another job you’re suited to. Check the exact definition.
How long you’re off work before payments start. Match it to your sick leave and savings.
How long payments can last. Short periods cost less but stop sooner on a long illness.
What’s taken off your payment, such as ACC, other insurance or income you still earn.
Agreed Value vs Indemnity vs Loss of Earnings
The payment type is the biggest choice you’ll make. It decides how your monthly payment is set and how it’s taxed.
How income protection payments are worked out
| Agreed value | Indemnity | Loss of earnings | |
|---|---|---|---|
| How payment is set | An insured amount agreed when you take out cover, subject to policy terms | A share of your income assessed when you claim | Your lost income, or a comparison of calculations, depending on the policy |
| Proof of income at claim | Amount set upfront, but the insurer may still ask for financial information | Yes | Yes |
| Maximum cover (Chubb Life example) | 62.5% of income up to $70,000, then lower | 75% of income up to $320,000 | 75% of income up to $320,000 |
| Tax treatment | Depends on the product and policy option | Depends on the product and policy option | Depends on the product and policy option |
Sources: Chubb Life; Fidelity Life; Partners Life. Check the insurer’s information and speak with a tax adviser about tax.
How NZ Insurers' Income Protection Compares
Here’s what six insurers publish about their income protection, as at November 2026.
Income protection by insurer, November 2026
Scroll sideways to see more →
| Insurer | Payment types | Maximum monthly cover | Waiting periods | Benefit periods | Disability test (standard jobs) | ACC deducted? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AIA | Agreed value, indemnity, loss of earnings | See policy | 4 weeks to 2 years | 2, 5 years, to 65 or 70 | Depends on cover type and job | Yes. Mortgage, Income or Rent Cover only offsets ACC above $7,500 a month |
| Asteron Life | Loss of earnings, Loss of Earnings Plus | See policy | You choose | 2, 5 years, to 65 or 70 | See policy wording | Yes on Loss of Earnings Plus |
| Chubb Life | Agreed value, indemnity, loss of earnings, loss of earnings ultra | Up to $30,000 (agreed value, indemnity); $25,000 (loss of earnings) | 4 weeks to 2 years | 2, 5 years, to 65 or 70 | Your pre-disability job | Other income deducted |
| Fidelity Life | Agreed value, indemnity | $30,000 | 2 weeks to 2 years | 2, 5 years, to 65 or 70 | Your normal job | Other income deducted |
| nib (Life & Living) | Agreed amount, illness only | $6,000 | 30 days | 2 or 5 years | Any job you're suited to | Yes |
| Partners Life | Agreed value (product reviewed) | $40,000 | 4 weeks to 2 years | 2, 5 years, to 65 or 70 | Your usual job | Yes |
Sources: AIA; Asteron Life; Chubb Life; Fidelity Life; nib, nib cover options; Partners Life. Terms summarised; the policy wording decides every claim.
These are published examples, not a full list of insurers or options. Maximum cover is also limited to a share of your income, and some options depend on your occupation class.
The biggest difference is nib’s direct cover: it pays for illness only, uses an “any occupation” test and requires at least 25 hours a week with one employer (nib). Other policies in this comparison cover illness and injury, subject to their terms. How an insurer decides whether you’re unable to work can also depend on the policy option and your occupation.
Not sure which type suits your job? A licensed NZ financial adviser can compare policies from several insurers for you.
Claims Acceptance Rates: What the Numbers Mean
Several NZ insurers publish claims acceptance figures above 90%. However, the figures cover different products, periods and types of claims, so they can’t be compared directly or used to rank income protection insurers.
Published claims figures
Scroll sideways to see more →
| Insurer | Published figure | What it covers | Period |
|---|---|---|---|
| AIA | 91% of all claims received | All products | 2025 |
| Asteron Life | 97% overall; over 95% in each category | Trauma, life and income protection | 1 July 2023 to 30 June 2024 |
| Fidelity Life | 93% of new claims | All products | Year to 30 June 2025 |
| Partners Life | 95% of assessed claims | All products | 1 April 2024 to 31 March 2025 |
| Chubb Life | 96% of all claims received | All products and channels | 2024 calendar year |
| nib | No published rate found |
Sources: AIA; Asteron Life; Chubb Life; Fidelity Life; Partners Life.
Notice the wording: “claims received”, “assessed claims” and “new claims” are counted differently. Insurers also commonly decline claims when a condition doesn’t meet the policy definition, when health information wasn’t disclosed at application, or when someone recovers before the waiting period ends (Good Returns). Accurate health information matters when you apply. So does understanding what the policy covers and the conditions you must meet before a claim is paid.
Do You Need Income Protection If You Have ACC?
ACC covers injuries, not illness. It pays up to 80% of your earnings if an accident stops you working (ACC). If cancer, a heart condition or mental illness stopped you working, ACC wouldn’t pay.
Most income protection deducts ACC payments for the same injury, so you don’t get paid twice. Some cover types treat ACC differently. AIA’s Mortgage, Income or Rent Cover only offsets ACC on payments above $7,500 a month (AIA), and Asteron Life’s Agreed Value Plus mortgage cover has no ACC offsets (Asteron Life). These policies calculate payments differently, so compare their benefits, exclusions and premiums before deciding.
Is Income Protection Worth It?
Income protection may be worth exploring if losing your pay for several months would make it difficult to meet your bills. Its value depends on your savings, sick leave, other household income and the cover available to you.
Reasons to Explore It
You rely on your pay for the mortgage or rent, have limited savings or sick leave, are self-employed, or would struggle if an illness kept you off work for months.
Reasons It May Be Less Relevant
You have enough savings to cover a long time off work, another income in your household that covers your costs, or generous long-term sick leave through your employer.
Income protection doesn’t cover redundancy. Some insurers let you add redundancy cover for a limited time. See our redundancy insurance guide.
Is income protection tax deductible? It depends on the payment type. Insurers say indemnity premiums are generally deductible because the payments are taxed, while agreed value premiums usually aren’t deductible and the payments aren’t taxed (Fidelity Life). Check with a tax adviser for your situation.
Want to compare income protection options? A licensed NZ financial adviser can explain the differences for your job and budget.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who has the best income protection insurance in NZ?
No insurer is best for everyone. Policies differ on payment type, the disability test, waiting and benefit periods, and what’s deducted from your payment. A licensed adviser can compare which policy is strongest for your job, income and budget.
Is it worth paying for income protection insurance?
It can be if you rely on your income and couldn’t cover months without pay. ACC only covers injuries, so income protection is the main way to replace income lost to illness. It may be less relevant if you have large savings or another income that covers your costs.
How much does income protection cost in NZ?
It depends on your age, job, health, the amount you cover, the waiting period, the benefit period and the payment type. A longer waiting period or shorter benefit period lowers the premium. A licensed adviser can get quotes for your situation.
What's the difference between agreed value and indemnity?
Agreed value pays an amount fixed when you take out cover, so you don’t need to prove your income at claim time. Indemnity pays a share of your income when you claim, so you’ll need to show evidence of it. The tax treatment also differs.
Is income protection insurance tax deductible in NZ?
It depends on the payment type. Insurers say indemnity premiums are generally deductible, while agreed value premiums usually aren’t. Check with a tax adviser for your situation.
Does income protection pay if I'm already getting ACC?
Usually, but it’s reduced by your ACC payments for the same injury. Some cover types treat ACC differently, such as AIA’s Mortgage, Income or Rent Cover, which only offsets ACC on payments above $7,500 a month. ACC doesn’t cover illness, so for illness claims there’s no ACC payment to deduct.
Can I get income protection if I'm self-employed?
Some income protection policies are available to self-employed people. Loss of earnings cover calculates payments using income lost at claim time, while other options use different methods. Eligibility and income evidence requirements vary, and nib’s direct cover requires work for a single employer.
Does income protection cover redundancy?
No. Income protection pays if illness or injury stops you working. Some insurers let you add redundancy cover for an extra premium. See our redundancy insurance guide.
Compare Income Protection With an Adviser
A licensed NZ financial adviser can compare policies from several insurers and explain the differences for your situation.
Free quotes. No obligation.
Sources
All checked November 2026.
- ACC: How weekly compensation payments work
- AIA New Zealand: Income Protection Insurance brochure (2026)
- Asteron Life: Income Protection brochure (May 2025)
- Asteron Life: Mortgage and Living Cover brochure
- Asteron Life: Life Insurer of the Year reports 97% claims payout rate (December 2024)
- Chubb Life: Income Cover brochure (CIG0007 V5, May 2026)
- Fidelity Life: Income Protection Cover factsheet (June 2025). Available from Fidelity Life or your adviser.
- Good Returns: Chubb Life pays 96% of claims (August 2025)
- Fidelity Life: Fidelity Life pays out $247.7 million in claims in FY25 (26 November 2025)
- Good Returns: Fidelity v Partners: Who pays out the most in claims? (January 2026)
- nib: Life & Living Insurance wording (July 2025)
- nib: Life and living cover options
- Partners Life: Journey Plan Income Cover Agreed Value fact sheet (effective 27 October 2025). Available from Partners Life or your adviser.
- My Insurance Quotes: Redundancy insurance in NZ
- ACC: Calculating weekly compensation for employees
My Insurance Quotes is not an insurer or financial adviser. We pass your details to a licensed NZ financial adviser who contacts you about your options. Read how we work on our Disclosure page.
This information is general in nature and does not take your personal circumstances into account. An appropriately licensed financial adviser can help you understand options relevant to you.
Spot an error? Email hello@myinsurancequotes.co.nz.